Profitability Framework

In the first step of the profitability framework, clarifying the problem statement involves asking precise and targeted questions to understand the issue without making premature assumptions. The goal is to scope the problem accurately and gather necessary information before proceeding to deeper analysis.

​

When we discuss valid scoping questions, they should focus on defining key terms and understanding the breadth of the problem. For example, if a company is facing profitability issues, one of the first things to clarify is what profitability means in this context. Valid questions could include:

• "When we say profitability, are we referring to net profit margin, operating profit, or gross profit?"

• "Is the profitability decline specific to our company, or is it something affecting the entire industry?"

• "Are we analyzing absolute profits or profit margins relative to our competitors?"

• "Is this issue being driven by a decline in revenue or increased costs?"

​​

These questions aim to gather concrete data and define the scope of the issue before jumping to any conclusions. For instance, a question like "Is the drop in profitability related to external factors like market downturns or internal inefficiencies?" would help distinguish between broader market problems and company-specific challenges.

​

By contrast, questions that jump to conclusions can derail the analysis by assuming an answer without proper investigation. An example would be: "Is our marketing strategy failing?" This presumes that the problem lies in marketing without any prior evidence to support that assumption. Similarly, "Should we cut down our product range?" is premature, as it proposes a solution before identifying the root cause of the problem.

 

Irrelevant questions—those that don’t relate to understanding the core issue—distract from the process. For example, in a case of profitability decline, asking "What color are our branding materials?" has no bearing on the immediate issue unless brand perception is part of the decline.

​

Case Examples

​

Case 1: "Fintech Fumble" – The Case of the Missing Margins

Context:
A rapidly growing fintech startup, PayTapp, has been killing it with user growth. Everyone’s buzzing about their slick mobile app and seamless payment gateway. But here’s the catch – despite all that traction, profitability has been on a steady decline for the last three quarters.

​

Problem:
Profits are shrinking, but no one’s sure exactly where the leak is.

​

Valid Scoping Questions:

• "When we talk about profitability, are we focusing on net profit margins, or is it more about operating margins?"

• "Is the profitability dip a result of higher customer acquisition costs or has there been a change in transaction fees?"

 

What You Don't Ask:

• "Is our app design the issue?" – We’re talking about profits here, not UX issues, unless you have direct evidence that app usability is tanking your bottom line.

• "Should we cut marketing spending?" – Jumping straight to solutions like slashing marketing budgets doesn’t help clarify the problem yet.

Case 2: "E-comm Crunch" – What’s Eating Up the Profits?

Context:
An online fashion retailer, TrendHub, known for trendy streetwear, has seen its revenue skyrocket during the pandemic. But despite the booming sales, profits have mysteriously slumped over the last fiscal year.

 

Problem:
Revenue is high, but profits aren’t following the same trend.

 

Valid Scoping Questions:

• "When you say profitability, are we looking at gross profit (after COGS) or net profit (after all expenses)?"

• "Are increased shipping costs or returns contributing to our declining profit margins?"

• "Is this profitability problem across all categories, or is it focused on a few product lines that have higher return rates or discounts?"

 

What You Don't Ask:

• "Is it time to revamp the website?" – Not really relevant at this point. The website’s probably doing its job bringing in traffic and sales. Let’s not get distracted.

• "Should we launch a new product line?" – Hold on! Before thinking about new products, focus on fixing the profit problem within the existing lines.

 

In both cases, the goal is to get specific about the problem before diving into solutions. Clarifying profitability by honing in on the right metrics and specific areas of concern helps avoid wild goose chases and zeroes in on what’s actually going wrong.